Abstract
Understanding the evolution of altruistic behaviors has been a long-standing challenge in both evolutionary and behavioral biology. Inclusive fitness theory, proposed by Hamilton (1964), provides a framework for explaining the evolution of altruism by considering the genetic relatedness between individuals. However, the mechanisms underlying the emergence and maintenance of altruistic behaviors remain complex. Cooperative game theory offers insights into how the interlocking contingencies responsible for cooperative interactions can emerge and sustain among unrelated individuals. This blog represents an attempt to formulate an Relational Frame/Game Theory account of the observations of Inclusive Fitness Theory, with particular focus on the Hyper-Dimensional-Multi Level (HDML) model of RFT. The combinatorial integration of these frameworks suggests a novel perspective on the origin and sustained occurrence of cooperative and altruistic behavior
Introduction
The evolution of altruism, where an individual incurs a cost to benefit another, poses a significant puzzle in biology and behavior analysis. Altruistic behaviors seemingly contradict the principles of natural selection, which favor self-interested behaviors that maximize individual fitness. Inclusive fitness theory, introduced by W.D. Hamilton in the 1960s, addresses this puzzle as a natural outcome of genetic relatedness between individuals that determines otherwise difficult to explain “altruistic” behaviors. However, the applicability of inclusive fitness theory beyond kin relationships remains debated. Cooperative game theory provides an alternative framework to understand the emergence of cooperation, even among unrelated individuals, by analyzing the strategic interactions and potential payoffs involved. In this paper, we investigate how cooperative outcomes, as predicted by game theory, can complement inclusive fitness theory in elucidating the evolution of altruistic behaviors.
Inclusive Fitness Theory
Inclusive fitness theory proposes that individuals can increase their genetic representation in future generations not only through their own offspring but also by aiding the reproductive success of relatives who share a proportion of their genes. This concept is encapsulated in Hamilton's rule, which states that altruistic behaviors evolve when the cost to the actor, multiplied by the genetic relatedness between the actor and the recipient, exceeds the benefit to the recipient. Kin selection, a mechanism driven by inclusive fitness, explains many instances of altruism observed in nature, such as the cooperative behaviors exhibited by social insects like ants and bees.
Cooperative Game Theory
Cooperative game theory provides a framework for analyzing situations where individuals can achieve better outcomes through cooperation rather than pure self-interest. In cooperative games, players can form coalitions and negotiate mutually beneficial outcomes. The core concept in cooperative game theory is the notion of a stable coalition, where no subset of players has an incentive to defect and form a new coalition. Various solution concepts, such as the Nash bargaining solution and the core, offer insights into predicting stable outcomes in cooperative games.
Relational Frame Theory and the HDML Model
Relational Frame Theory (RFT) proposes that human behavior is influenced by framing behavior that allows humas to relate otherwise arbitrary and physically unrelated stimuli and events through language and cognition. The HDML model of RFT describes how individuals derive relations between stimuli via a hierarchically iteration of mutual entailment, combinatorial entailment and transformation for function, leading to complex emergent verbal behavior structures (e.g., verbal behavior cusps), capacities and competencies.
Intersection of Inclusive Fitness and Cooperative Game Theory
While inclusive fitness theory primarily focuses on kin selection and genetic relatedness, cooperative game theory extends the analysis to cooperative interactions among unrelated individuals. By considering the strategic dynamics of cooperation, game theory can elucidate scenarios where altruistic behaviors may arise even in the absence of genetic relatedness. For instance, iterated prisoner's dilemma models demonstrate how reciprocal altruism can evolve through repeated interactions, leading to the emergence of cooperative strategies that benefit all players involved.
Moreover, cooperative game theory provides a framework for understanding the role of reputation (as a verbal phenomenon), and the effect of interlocking contingencies of reciprocity and punishment in maintaining cooperation within social groups. Reputation-based relational mechanisms, where individuals cooperate with those known to reciprocate cooperation and punish defectors, can stabilize cooperative outcomes even in large groups of unrelated individuals. Such mechanisms align with the principles of inclusive fitness by promoting cooperation among individuals who interlocked behavior maximizes group fitness.
Integration of Framework
Integrating Inclusive Fitness Theory, game theory, and RFT offers a comprehensive approach to understanding altruism. The HDML model provides insights into how individuals form relational networks that influence social interactions and decision-making processes. By considering the role of language and cognition, we can better understand the emergence of cooperative strategies and altruistic behaviors, even among unrelated individuals.
Case Studies and Suggestive Evidence. Empirical studies across various taxa provide support for the combined insights of inclusive fitness and cooperative game theory. For example, studies on cooperative breeding in birds demonstrate how individuals can cooperate to raise offspring, thereby increasing the inclusive fitness of all group members. Similarly, experiments with social mammals, such as wolves and dolphins, highlight the importance of reciprocal altruism and cooperation in facilitating group living and resource sharing.
In addition, studies combining game theory, RFT, and evolutionary biology may provide support for this integrated framework. For example, experiments using economic games demonstrate how individuals' relational competencies affect cooperative behavior and decision-making. Moreover, studies on reputation and reciprocity, as effectual verbal narratives representative of the action of complex contingencies (cf., Lyang, 2006), highlight the importance of relational networks in maintaining cooperation within social groups.
Conclusion
Inclusive fitness theory and cooperative game theory offer complementary perspectives on the evolution of altruistic behaviors. While inclusive fitness theory emphasizes the role of genetic relatedness and kin selection, cooperative game theory provides a broader framework for understanding cooperation among unrelated individuals. Integrating Inclusive Fitness Theory, game theory, and Relational Frame Theory offers a promising avenue for understanding the evolution of altruism. By considering the relational processes and mechanisms underlying social behavior, such as those suggested by the HDML model, we can elucidate how relational responding contributes to cooperative outcomes and the emergence of altruistic behaviors. Future research should further explore these putative interactions between genetic relatedness, cognitive/relational processes, and social dynamics to deepen our understanding of altruism in evolutionary social biology.
References
Barnes-Holmes, D., Barnes-Holmes, Y., & Cullinan, V. (2000). Relational frame theory and Skinner's Verbal Behavior: A possible synthesis. The Behavior Analyst, 23(1), 69-84.
Hamilton, W. D. (1964). The genetical evolution of social behaviour. Journal of theoretical biology, 7(1), 1-52.
Hayes, S. C., Barnes-Holmes, D., & Roche, B. (2001). Relational frame theory: A post-Skinnerian account of human language and cognition. Springer Science & Business Media.
Layng, T. V. J. (2006), Emotions and emotional behavior: A constructional approach to understanding some social benefits of aggression. Brazilian Journal of Behavior Analysis, 2, 2, 155 – 170.
Nowak, M. A. (2006). Five rules for the evolution of cooperation. science, 314(5805), 1560-1563.
West, S. A., Griffin, A. S., & Gardner, A. (2007). Social semantics: altruism, cooperation, mutualism, strong reciprocity and group selection. Journal of evolutionary biology, 20(2), 415-432.