Skip to main content

What Is Good Evidence for an Evolving Psychological Science? Pseudoscience, Parsimony, and Field Psychology - An ACBS Superlab Presentation

Event Date
-
Presenter
Angela Coreil

Please join us for Superlab with Angela Coreil on Wednesday, March 17 at 3pm Eastern.  You can register here

Title: What Is Good Evidence for an Evolving Psychological Science? Pseudoscience, Parsimony, and Field Psychology

Abstract: Distinguishing science from pseudoscience in psychotherapy raises a question that extends beyond identifying unsupported treatments: What constitutes adequate evidence for the explanations that psychological science produces? An intervention may demonstrate effectiveness without validating its proposed mechanisms, while widely accepted psychological constructs may remain difficult to reconcile with observable behavior. These problems invite scrutiny not only of pseudoscientific practices but also of the assumptions and methods underlying mainstream psychological research.

This SuperLab examines how psychology might advance toward a more coherent and cumulative science. The replication crisis, limitations of diagnostic classification, and proliferation of compound psychological variables reveal difficulties in translating population-level findings into explanations of individual behavior. We consider the role of parsimony, functional analysis, idiographic longitudinal research, and the distinction between describing behavioral patterns and explaining their functional relations.

Drawing on field psychology and interbehavioral perspectives, the discussion explores how diverse theoretical traditions might contribute to a shared scientific framework without requiring agreement on their explanatory constructs. This SuperLab invites critical examination of the conceptual and methodological foundations needed to develop, evaluate, and improve psychological interventions.

Bio: Angela Coreil, PhD, BCBA, is a Visiting Assistant Professor of Psychology at the University of Louisiana at Lafayette, a licensed psychologist, and director of the THRIVE Research Lab. Her work integrates clinical behavior analysis, contextual behavioral science, and interbehavioral psychology. I work to advance the scientific foundations of psychological assessment and intervention. My work examines how psychological events can be understood through functional relations, longitudinal behavioral measurement, and the analysis of verbal behavior within its context. Current projects explore computational functional analysis and emerging technologies for identifying clinically meaningful behavioral patterns. Drawing on experience as a clinician, clinical director, researcher, and educator, Dr. Coreil is particularly interested in improving the translation of psychological science into clinical decision-making. Her broader scientific agenda emphasizes conceptual precision, methodological accountability, and the integration of useful findings across therapeutic traditions.

Online/Virtual
Yes
Language
English